Gordon Prentice at Large - Politics in Newmarket

  • ClockTower-new720.jpg
  • Main Street 1940s_edited-1.jpg
  • Main Street snowstorm_edited-1.jpg
  • NewmarketMainStreet-Snowstorm720.jpg
  • NewmarketMainStreet720.jpg
  • NewmarketMainStreet1940s720.jpg
  • slessor-for-sale-720p.jpg
  • slessorvan01.jpg

On 10 November 2026 the Ford Government appointed the Mayor of Vaughan and former Ontario Liberal Party leader, Steven Del Duca, to York Regional Council as its powerful new Chair. 

The appointment was immediately condemned by Markham Mayor, Frank Scarpitti, whose municipality is the largest of nine in York Region by population.

Scarpitti, il capo di tutti capi, does not take prisoners. Behind that rich quietly modulated baritone lurks a hint of menace.

Scarpitti said Del Duca was “no friend of Markham” and was too close to the Premier, Doug Ford. And then for good measure he throws this in to the pot:

“I'll just say when the premier said the president of the United States could kiss a certain part of his anatomy, he forgot to say that he'd have to push Steven Del Duca out of the way.” 

Conflict of Interest

He says the appointment builds in a blatant conflict of interest.

“This model of a sitting mayor sitting as the regional Chair, it’s a blatant conflict of interest, in terms of advocating for your city and then also having the levers at the region to be able to have a particular outcome.”

And that Del Duca is Ford's cheerleader.

“Whatever the province wants, Steven Del Duca seems to be the cheerleader.”

“If Mr. Del Duca shows up for the inaugural (meeting on Nov. 26), that’ll be only the fifth or sixth time he has stepped in the council chamber in the last four years.”

So, I think we know where Frank Scarpitti stands.

On 17 January 2024 both gave oral evidence to the Province’s Standing Committee on Heritage, Infrastructure and Cultural Policy which was looking at Regional Governance. Scarpitti wanted to fuse a new City together from York Region’s nine municipalities. Del Duca favoured retaining the Region but downloading “all land planning matters” and other key functions to the lower tier and uploading fire and rescue to the Region. 

Independence

Del Duca’s policy has certainly evolved since June 2023 when he was pushing for independence for Vaughan. 

At York Regional Council on 29 June 2023 he said regional planners were engaged in institutional “self-preservation” who were trying to hang on to responsibilities that should go the lower teir municipalities. 

Newmarket Mayor John Taylor said Del Duca's comments were unnecessary, derogatory and inaccurate. Scarpitti and Pellegrini

It is hard to disagree with Scarpitti. Ford’s model for regional governance has been spatchcocked together over the years since Ford's first election as the Progressive Conservative Premier in 2018. It makes no sense. (Photo: Scarpitti on left)

Elected Chair to Appointed Chair

Back then Del Duca ran for Chair of York Regional Council but that campaign died the death on 27 July 2018.

On the day nominations closed, Ford announced the first direct election for Regional Chair would not go ahead.

In an opinion piece for the Toronto Star on 11 September 2018 Del Duca branded Ford a hypocrite for trumpeting the virtues of election over appointment and then going on do the exact opposite. (Click “read more” below for Del Duca’s opinion piece)

Shape-shifter

Steven Del Duca is the consumate shape-shifter, tailoring his views to what the moment demands.

During the Provincial election in 2022, Del Duca, then Liberal Leader, was accusing Ford of being a “climate change denier” who was using Highway 413 to benefit wealthy supporters. He said it was

“a waste of money and an environmental disaster in the making”.

Ford was “undermining and underfunding public education” whose record was “an embarrassment and you should be ashamed of yourself”.

Performative

All this was performative. Something Del Duca had to say and do as Leader of the Liberals. He resigned on election night, 2 June 2022, and put those views behind him. Baggage to be dumped in the search of a new career in municipal politics. 

Del Duca is now one of Doug Ford’s firm favourites.

Hands up all those who are surprised.

But, for the moment, the main question remains unanswered.

Where will Steven Del Duca's loyalties now lie?

With Vaughan, with York Region or with the Premier's Office?

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.


Toronto Star 11 September 2018

By Steven Del Duca Opinion

Since Premier Doug Ford announced he would use unprecedented legislation to interfere with selected municipal elections, almost all the public focus and media coverage has centred on the City of Toronto.

That’s understandable because dramatically reducing the size of Toronto’s council to 25 from 47, midcampaign, is a big story that deserves attention and scrutiny.

But the Better Local Governments Act also eliminated the elections for regional chair in Niagara, Muskoka, Peel and York — and that should be a big deal.

In each of these municipalities, regional chairs will no longer be elected by the people. They will, instead, once again be appointed by regional councillors.

In public comments made to justify this move, both Ford and Municipal Affairs Minister Steve Clark suggested cancelling these elections (which had already begun) would eliminate a layer of politician.

Not true.

The affected regions will still each have a chair. Each chair will still earn a salary, will continue to be supported by staff and will lead these councils. They just won’t be chosen by the people on whose behalf they work.

Not a single taxpayer dollar will be saved.

Ford and Clark then went on to say that “mature” regions, such as Halton, Durham and Waterloo, would continue to elect their chairs on Oct. 22.

They didn’t say how they define mature regions versus, say, immature regions.

In fact, all four regions were established in the early 1970s at about the same time as Halton, Durham and Waterloo.

Combined, the so-called immature regions are home to more than three million residents and Peel and York are, by far, Ontario’s two largest regions by population.

These four regions are also home to university and college campuses, a subway, GO train corridors, office towers, rich farmland, globally recognized tourist destinations — and their neighbourhoods are full of diverse, talented and hard-working families.

And those families pay the bulk of their property taxes to … the region.

In York, for example, a little more than 50 per cent of a property tax bill goes to the regional government, which has an operating budget of $3 billion. That’s $3 billion in taxes given by 1.2 million residents to support York Regional Police, York Region and Viva Rapid Transit, emergency medical services, community and health services, social housing, water delivery and waste water treatment, regional roads and solid waste management.

That doesn’t seem immature to me.

In the latest twist, an Ontario Superior Court judge struck down the provisions impacting Toronto — ruling them an unconstitutional infringement on the freedom of expression rights of both candidates and voters in the 416.

Ford thundered that the court decision would be appealed, and that the legislature would be recalled so Bill 5 could be reintroduced with the added protection of the Charter’s notwithstanding clause.

There is certainly no shortage of drama these days on the municipal stage in Toronto and I will leave the legal analysis to those who have far more expertise in this area than me.

But here’s the thing: When he announced he would invoke the notwithstanding clause for the first time in Ontario’s history, Ford repeatedly emphasized that his democratic election trumps the appointment of a judge.

When he said “I was elected … and the judge was appointed” he was saying — very clearly — he believes that appointed office-holders are not as legitimate as those chosen by the people.

Let that sink in for a second.

Putting aside the absurdity and the dangerousness of his assault on the independence and freedom of the judiciary, Ford’s latest comments are ironic and hypocritical.

How can it be that the premier believes a resident in Peel shouldn’t have the right to vote for their regional chair, when someone living nearby in Halton does?

And given we now know Ford believes elected officials are “above” appointed officials somehow, will he treat the elected regional chairs of Durham, Halton and Waterloo better than he will the appointed chairs of Peel, York, Niagara and Muskoka?

No one knows for sure. Because no one, so far, has been asking.

When the legislature once again debates Bill 5, I have no doubt that there will be vigorous denunciations coming from the opposition parties about Ford’s decision.

This is as it should be.

But I hope that those same opposition members, along with our media, will refuse to give him a free pass on his double-standard for regional chairs.

Moreover, it is high time that members of Ford’s own caucus who represent Peel, York, Niagara and Muskoka remind their leader that their communities are not immature, and are just as deserving of democratically chosen representation as their neighbours.

Steven Del Duca is the former MPP for Vaughan and he was a registered candidate for the position of York Region chair.

Subscribe for updates

Get an email when there is a new post. Unsubscribe anytime.